IB003N-SHT Honest Review

Not long ago, I bought this beacons from Alibaba. What attracted me most and main consideration of choosing this beacons against a number of China made beacons are the following:

1. It can broadcast 3 frames(Ibeacon, eddystone(URL or UID) and Accelerometer)
2. It has a specialize temperature sensor
3. It has buzzer

For some reasons, the Chinese seller had delayed the delivery considering that I paid expensive shipping charge($30) but the delivery time took almost a month which is just like having it shipped for free via postal mail(small packets) but I didn't mind it since the product I bought are really loaded with tons features.

Ok the item arrived and my initial testing which is to check whether it really can broadcast the 3 frames and it worked. Days later, when I tried to check the data being broadcasted and verify if it really has all the goodies and to my surprised, I found that it is not what they claimed it be which really had disappointed me. Here are my actual findings:

1. Ibeacon and Temperature Sensor issue. According to their documentation, the temperature readings are being broadcasted at the major and minor (least significant bits). During my test, I could not find the major value and the minor value turns out to be the least significant bit. I reported this issue to the Chinese seller and after a few days of discussion, they have admitted that the major value is unusable. They did not mentioned this in the technical documentation they have provided nor on their advertisement. Another issue I found is that most of the time, the temperature reading is 0 which is weird and I found this to be a hardware defect.
2. Eddystone issue. The data being broadcasted is not Eddystone standard compliant. The main identifer of Eddystone "AAFE" is missing, I have confirmed this because even nRFConnect can not identify the frame as Eddystone. Their counting of UID begins at the "02" byte which is absolutely wrong. The transmittion power is missing. And worst is that when I tried to populate the characteristics "FFD02", the Eddystone frame goes blank which stunned or shocked me.
3. Buzzer Issue. 20dB is very loud, and based on their technical documentaion, it can be adjusted through GATT. But during my testing, the loudness could not be adjusted. With that loudness, I could hardly hear it.

After I found these defects, I stopped the testing of other features. I have already concluded that the IB003N-SHT is full of defects. I tried to negotiate with the Chinese seller by returning the product to them due to the above mentioned defects, but I got this reply from them:

"Our products have no defects, but if you are not satisfied, you may return the items to us. But pls do not include the batteries. We will deduct $2 for each item for the batteries. We will test each items after receiving them from you and we find no defects, we will refund your money. Shipping and delivery charge will be deducted."

I think this is not what I have expected from them, with this transaction, I would suffer $127 loss which way too much.